Fiscal consolidation will require painful choices on taxing and spending: tax cuts introduced in 2001 and 2003 which will expire in 2010 will have to be allowed to expire and an unindexed alternative minimum tax will have to be left in place; spending growth will have to be compressed in defence, education, energy and other non-social spending to allow room for growth in entitlement spending. These are difficult political decisions; if they are avoided borrowing will continue to finance the fiscal deficit and exacerbate the current account imbalance in the years ahead. A recurrence of crisis is possible if market participants refuse to finance this borrowing. An innovative political response is required to signal the necessary determination to achieve a credible plan for fiscal consolidation after 2010. A bipartisan task force consisting of congressional and administration representatives could prepare a long-term fiscal plan that is ‘fast tracked’ through the political process by subjecting it to an up-or-down vote in both houses of Congress after the2010 mid-term elections.
Despite these major domestic preoccupations the United States has engaged with Asia, most colorfully when President Obama concluded a November 14 foreign policy speech in Tokyo by describing himself as America’s first Pacific President. This speech covered a wide range of economic and political issues. While reiterating support for the Japan alliance it recognized China as a partner in addressing economic issues and North Korea. The reality is deep economic interdependence with China because of their complementary imbalances: China’s excess savings have financed US excess consumption. Both parties move to unwind the imbalances. If there was ever a case for close policy coordination, this is it. The US dollar must continue to depreciate beyond what followed the unwinding of safe haven inflows during the 2008 crisis as domestic saving rises. Chinese yuan appreciation is expected to resume in 2010 but at a gradual pace that recognizes the political complexities of the resulting relative price changes in China.
With slow US growth and high unemployment for at least another year, maintaining momentum for trade openness and liberalization is of central importance. Clearly a major signal of the necessary commitment is needed by completing the Korean-US Free Trade Agreement (KORUS) and proceeding with the US application to join the Trans-Pacific Partnership (TPP), as Obama has indicated he will do.
Follow-through in 2010 is critical. Key indicators that the United States is coming to grips with its domestic challenges and engaging the region will include the outlines of a credible bipartisan fiscal consolidation plan by mid-year, implementation of major financial regulatory reforms, completion of KORUS and moves to join the TPP. A number of Asian governments also want America to stay engaged in order to balance the influence of what will soon be the world’s three largest economies, Japan, China and India. But because the regions’ economic architecture is still evolving, most recently in the light of six Asian members now participating in the G20, the American response should be one of careful acquiescence with Asians’ preferences for any role beyond APEC membership.
This is part of the special feature: 2009 in review and the year ahead.
Wendy Dobson is former associate deputy minister of finance in Ottawa and professor at the Rotman School of Management, is author of Gravity Shift: How Asia’s New Economic Powerhouses will Shape the 21st Century.
Happy new year, Wendy,
Thanks for a good assessment on US economic policy issues, especially on the macro-economic challenges.
You may have read the recent assessments of a potential TPP on this site,
A US undertaking to desist from petty acts of protectionism would be far more meaningful.
As in the case of the Australia-USA agreement, any TPP will not lead to more than token new access to US markets in sensitive products, or any real insurance against contingent protectionism. And even then Congress may refuse to vote on it.
Best wishes,
Andrew